top of page
You are in the PFD Zone

1.3.4 Information falsified

In a few cases (largely observation records in prisons and secure MH units) data was deliberately falsified.

- May be partly explained (though not excused) by a lack of time or capacity to create accurate records, but the prevalence of the issue suggests it may be deeper rooted than this – a disregard for the importance of timely and accurate record-keeping and/or for the fact that other professionals might rely on that data

PFD reports citing this issue

sent to

MH unit (inc for people detained under MH Act)

Mahamoud was detained (sectioned) in a mental health ward after a fall in the street. He was meant to be under 15-minute observations, but at 17.40 a mental health nurse noticed that observation records weree missing for 17.00,17.15 and 17.30.

sent to

MH unit (inc for people detained under MH Act)

Anna was sectioned as she had suicidal thoughts. She was not observed as she should have been, partly due to staffing pressures, but staff backfilled the observation records to show that obs were being carried out correctly. The Coroner also noted an issue about messages from Anna's mother not being recorded or passed to staff, and about poor handover from day to night shift staff.

sent to

MH unit (inc for people detained under MH Act)

Morgan-Rose took her life while sectioned under the MHA. She was 18 with a diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder; her transition from Children's to Adult1 Social Care had been badly managed, with a lack of information transfer between the two serevices and with no consideration of her own anxieties. MHU staff consistently failed to engage with Morgan-Rose, to the point where she felt they didn't have time for her. They failed to monitor her as they were required to, falsifying observation records and relying on the Oxevision automated observation system instead of face-to-face observations. When Oxevision triggered an alarm to say she had been unattended in the bathroom for three minutes, which should have resulted in an immediate welfare check, the system was reset by an unknown person and Morgan-Rose was left in the bathroom for 50 minutes. Staff had also failed to pick up on warning signals in her behaviour which should have led to heightened alertness. Basic record-keeping was extremely poor, as was the oversight and monitoring of records by senior staff.

sent to

Prison - operational staff

On 29 September 2022, Kevin was discovered deceased in his cell, having died as a result of ligature asphyxiation. He had a long history of mental ill health, paranoia and self-harm behaviours. He was on an Assessment, Care in Custody and Teamwork (ACCT) plan. However: - Information about Kevin's needs was not being shared between staff at handover - The ACCT plan itself was unavailable to staff on the day of his death - a day known to be a trigger date for Kevin - as it had been removed for quality assurance - Staff were not trained in ACCT observations, and some were simply completing "signs of life" checks" - After Kevin's death, records were falsified to state that ACCT checks had been carried out

sent to

MH unit (inc for people detained under MH Act)

Information about the frequency of Charlie's observations was not completed until after his death. The Coroner noted two earlier PFD reports about the same MHU which raised the same concern.

sent to

MH unit (inc for people detained under MH Act)

Multiple concerns about the Trust's approach to risk assessment (including a failure to prescribe appropriate medication); the way they carried out observations; and failure to pay regard to information provided by Larry's partner, which was put on the record but ignored.

sent to

Prison - operational staff

Two consecutive welfare checks were omitted by different officers; one completed the log to say he had carried out the check.

sent to

MH unit (inc for people detained under MH Act)

Missed observations; falsified observation records; lack of supervision of newly qualified staff
bottom of page